response

Ok- I just typed in your comment and hit something and lost it. so here goes round two. Your analysis is insightful, well supported and so true. Why is it that he feels so much of an outsider? he is wanted yet he can't be accepted? will he ever be? Does society even today in certain circles accept those who are different.? heatcliff tries to belong but doea he ever fit in?
Could you also add to your reflection your metacognition piece. How you felt you contributed or were involved inthe discussion. Do you think you are doing ok adn actively grouwing from discussing the novel etc....

Overall, your analysis was very well done, I will have to sit and chat with your group because gthere is so much to discuss with your book and all the layers of what is occurring,.

Lit Circle Journal #1

This week we read the first 7 chapters of Wuthering Heights and began to analyze the setting and the difference/ similarities between Heathcliff and Lockwood. We noted that class seemed to be a defining attribute that Lockwood based his assumptions on, which tells not only of his character but the time of the novel. We focused on distinguishing factors between the two characters, such as Heathcliff being a "dark-skinned gypsy in aspect in dress and manners a gentleman..."- pg 11, a man who doesn’t conform to stereotypes, while Lockwood is more of the traditional image of class. Their appearances also somewhat reflect their identities; Heathcliff being a dark and mysteriously foreboding orphan. Lockwood on the other hand is a man very aware of his social standing and is willing to assert his perceived authority granted by class. As we delve deeper into the novel we learn of the twisted family tree that exists while we begin to question the concept of family. Although many of the characters are related, they often appear to be enemies who grieve at the presence of one another. It almost seems a warning of a dark past best not explored.

         We also explored the setting. It was dark and most foremost unwelcoming. Lockwood exists the prevailing cold and enters the mysterious house “without any introductory lobby or passage” – pg 11. He also notes that “in Wuthering heights the kitchen if forced to retreat” into the far corner of the house. – pg 10 This simple implication; the heart of this house is far hidden, and there is no welcome to be found here, further emphasizes how cold and desolate the scene is. The entire place screams outwardly against intrusion, and the quickening winds set an atmosphere of chaos and danger.

         As we read further we learned more of Heathcliff’s past, and questioned the connotations the book creates around darkness, pain and conflict. Our group concluded that each one of those reflections of Heathcliff was a result of the psychological and emotional suffering he experienced as a permanent outsider in a home that couldn’t accept him.